On June 10, 2024, the Cellule d’information pour la politique urbaine (CIPU) hosted its first workshop of the year, focusing on the crucial topic of climate-resilient urban development. The event took place at the Ellergronn Nature Reserve in Esch-sur-Alzette, where participants gathered to explore strategies that could help Luxembourg’s cities and municipalities adapt to the growing challenges posed by climate change.

The workshop commenced with a guided tour of the “Transition NOW” exhibition at the Ellergronn Nature Reserve. This exhibition highlighted how human activities affect the environment and the climate, underscoring the urgent need for cities to adapt to changing conditions. Following the tour, participants received a thematic introduction to key concepts such as resilience, climate resilience, and climate adaptation. Jeannot Behm, representing the city of Esch-sur-Alzette, presented the city’s ongoing activities related to climate change, resilience, and public awareness.

Guided tour through the exhibition Transition NOW at the Ellergronn Nature Reserve (Source: Ville d’Esch)

Following the introductory presentations, participants engaged in a collaborative group work phase that focused on key thematic areas related to climate-resilient urban development. Firstly, everyone moved through different groups to identify priorities and gather ideas across the four central themes: Urban and District Planning, Built Environment, Emergency Management and Crisis Communication, and Supply and Disposal Systems. These discussions were recorded on thematic posters to capture diverse perspectives and insights. In the subsequent phase, participants were divided into set groups, each focusing on one of the specific themes. They delved deeper into the identified priorities, discussing challenges, exploring potential solutions, and outlining concrete actions to enhance resilience in their respective areas.

Urban and District Planning: The discussions on urban and district planning focused on the importance of incorporating nature-based solutions to increase the resilience of cities. Participants explored the potential of the “sponge city” concept, which involves creating green spaces and water retention areas to manage stormwater and reduce urban heat islands. There was a strong emphasis on maintaining a balance between built environments and natural areas, implementing cooling strategies through tree planting and shaded public spaces, and promoting the “15-minute city” model to enhance local accessibility. Key messages included the need for comprehensive risk assessments, thoughtful urban design that prioritises sustainability, and the development of policies that encourage resilient urban planning practices.

Built Environment: In the group of the built environment, participants discussed strategies for designing and retrofitting buildings to withstand the impacts of climate change, such as heatwaves, heavy rainfall, and storms. The conversation highlighted the importance of using sustainable building materials and promoting low-tech, resource-efficient construction methods. Participants called for the development of clear legal frameworks and financial incentives to support climate-resilient architecture. Public sector building projects were seen as critical for demonstrating best practices and leading by example. The discussions concluded that a coordinated effort involving policymakers, architects, and builders is necessary to mainstream climate-resilient building practices.

Participants discussing priorities for climate resilience in urban and district planning (Source: Ville d’Esch)

Emergency Management and Crisis Communication: This group focused on the development of robust emergency management strategies and clear communication plans to ensure preparedness for extreme weather events. Participants stressed the importance of early warning systems, clearly defined action plans, and regular simulation exercises to enhance readiness. Community engagement emerged as a key theme, with discussions emphasising the need to educate the public about potential risks and appropriate responses. The session highlighted the necessity of strong coordination and the establishment of dedicated units composed of citizens and technical experts to oversee emergency management efforts.

Supply and Disposal Systems: The final group discussed sustainable approaches to managing water, energy, and waste in urban environments. Participants examined strategies for improving water quality, promoting water recycling, and implementing rainwater harvesting systems to reduce reliance on fresh water. The concept of the circular economy was central to discussions on waste management, with a focus on reusing materials and reducing overall waste production. The group also emphasised the importance of local renewable energy production and storage to ensure energy security and reduce carbon footprints. Key outcomes included the need for integrated planning that incorporates circular economy principles, local sourcing, and the exploitation of synergies between different urban systems.

Group work on identifying priorities for the different thematic fields (Source: Ville d’Esch)

After the vivid group discussions, the participants gathered in a final plenary session to reflect on the developed results. The guided tour through the exhibition “Transition Now” as well as the presentations emphasised the necessity of adapting urban spaces to the challenges imposed by climate change. The workshop highlighted the often-blurred lines between climate adaptation and climate resilience, revealing a need for clearer understanding and practical knowledge in these areas. Political support, resource allocation, public awareness, and effective collaboration among stakeholders were recognised as essential for the successful implementation of these strategies. Clear political and legal frameworks, both at the national and local level, were also deemed critical to support these efforts.

Building on these outcomes, the second CIPU workshop, which will take place on October 9, 2024, will focus on developing key elements of a climate resilience strategy at municipal level to strengthen Luxembourg’s urban areas. The goal is to identify starting points to actionable solutions that can be quickly implemented and contribute to long-term sustainable urban development, further sharpening the approaches discussed in this workshop.

If you are interested in a more detailed description of the workshop and the results of the group discussions, you can access the documentation here.

Contact

  • CIPU: cipu@zeyenbaumann.lu

References

The city of Esch-sur-Alzette has made a promising start as a leader in urban resilience, becoming the first city in Luxembourg to develop a resilience plan. Its objective is to enhance the city’s capacity to address a diverse range of challenges, including natural disasters such as floods and heatwaves, as well as technological disruptions such as cyberattacks and power outages.

Aerial view of Esch-sur-Alzette (Source: Ville d’Esch: https://administration.esch.lu/2023/01/27/esch-pionniere-presente-son-plan-de-resilience/)

Aim

The plan which was presented in January 2023 defines resilience as the ability of a system to withstand external shocks and maintain its essential functions, also applicable to a city. Therefore, the core objective of the Esch-sur-Alzette resilience plan is to guarantee the safety and well-being of its citizens during and after a crisis. By minimising potential damage and enabling a swift recovery after disruptive events, the plan fosters a more secure future for the city’s residents. In this objective, it defines measures to be taken and defines standards for the everyday work of the city of Esch.

Genesis and Composition

A dedicated working group, composed of representatives from five technical departments – IT Department, Industrial Services, Environmental Services, Municipal Works and Urban Development – initiated the creation of the resilience plan. Representatives from this working group now form the Operational Resilience Committee (“Comité de résilience operationnelle”), which is responsible for its coordination. This collaborative approach ensured a comprehensive perspective and the inclusion of expertise from various sectors.

The plan itself draws inspiration from good practices observed and exchanged about with other European actors proactive in the field of resilience. Cities like Rotterdam in the Netherlands and Vejle in Denmark, renowned for their approaches to crisis management, served as valuable models for Esch-sur-Alzette.

Urban resilience (created with ChatGPT)

Activities

The Esch-sur-Alzette resilience strategy adopts a layered approach akin to an onion, focusing on fortifying the city’s resilience from its core outwards. This entails securing the reliability of technical services on the inside, strengthening citizen-facing services and ultimately prioritising the well-being of both residents and businesses. The plan is built around 12 concrete actions strategically divided into three phases: before, during, and after a crisis.

Before the Crisis: Proactive Preparation. Each city department will assess its vulnerabilities and craft departmental crisis plans. These measures will involve updating safety protocols for critical infrastructure and implementing early warning systems to anticipate potential crises.

During the Crisis: Effective Response. Measures include pre-allocated budgets for crisis response activities, efficient damage assessment protocols, and documented departmental actions to ensure basic functionality and public safety. Additionally, backup plans as well as external and internal resource mobilisation strategies shall ensure a robust response even in unforeseen circumstances.

After the Crisis: Learning and Rebuilding. Regular training exercises and post-crisis debriefings will equip city departments to continuously improve their response capabilities. A structured approach to evaluating incidents will identify valuable lessons learned. Finally, Esch-sur-Alzette fosters a collaborative approach by sharing knowledge and best practices with partner cities, strengthening regional resilience. The plan is to proceed in seven steps. This includes the appointment of a “Chief Resilience Officer”, the regular discussion of resilience plans in the individual community services, the creation of Smart City use cases of technological solutions for increased resilience and the sharing of the plan with the member municipalities of the syndicate ProSud.

Resilience Matrix (Source: Ville d’Esch: https://administration.esch.lu/2023/01/27/esch-pionniere-presente-son-plan-de-resilience/)

Outlook

As a living document, the Esch-sur-Alzette resilience plan will continuously evolve to meet future challenges. The city plans to share its insights and experiences with neighbouring municipalities to foster synergies in resilience-building efforts. Furthermore, ongoing initiatives such as Smart City projects will leverage cutting-edge technologies to further enhance the city’s resilience. This pioneering initiative positions Esch-sur-Alzette as a model for urban resilience, proactively building a more secure and sustainable future for its citizens and potentially inspiring other Luxembourgish municipalities.

Contact

Ville d’Esch – Urban Development Division: https://administration.esch.lu/intro-et-contact/

References

Communication of the city of Esch (French): https://administration.esch.lu/2023/01/27/esch-pionniere-presente-son-plan-de-resilience/

Presentation of the resilience plan (French): https://esch.lu/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Presentation-Plan-de-resilience-Ville-dEsch.pdf

Newspaper article in tageblatt.lu (German): https://www.tageblatt.lu/headlines/velodukt-gratis-kurzzeitparkplaetze-und-ein-resilienzplan/

In October 2020, a significant milestone was achieved in the southern Luxembourg region, as 11 municipalities under the PRO-SUD syndicate joined the UNESCO Biosphere network, a label renowned as educational hubs for sustainable development. This move accelerates a series of initiatives aimed at actively fostering sustainable development.

One of the key initiatives that followed was the collaborative formulation of a “territorial vision” for the region, harmonised with the objectives outlined in the Luxembourgish National Territorial Development Plan (PDAT). The “territorial vision” strategy is taking shape with the Mission Zero Carbon – 11 municipalities for the ecological transition launched in April 2023 and marked by the signing of a Letter of Intent by PRO-SUD’s 11 municipalities, the Minister of Spatial Planning, and the Minister of Environment.

Aim

The primary goal of Mission Zero Carbone is to foster regional collaboration towards achieving carbon neutrality by 2050, in alignment with the Luxembourgish national territorial development plan (PDAT). To realize this ambition, a range of strategies has been identified, encompassing:

  • Reducing energy consumption: Advocating for energy-saving practices and technologies across public sectors.
  • Increasing renewable energy usage: Promoting the adoption and integration of renewable energy sources, such as solar panels.
  • Enhancing energy efficiency through regional energy planning.
  • Promoting sustainable mobility: Advocating for active transportation modes like cycling and walking and enhancing public transport infrastructure.
  • Safeguarding and restoring natural habitats: Ensuring the preservation of existing ecosystems and rejuvenating degraded areas to amplify their carbon sequestration potential.
  • Educational programs engage students, teachers, and cultural associations in the ecological transition, fostering active participation and awareness to drive sustainable change.

A first concrete project of this regional approach is the bioclimatic map launched in partnership with the Luxembourg Institute of Sciences and Technology (LIST) and Geonet by acquiring vital data and conducting precise analyses on the urban bio-climate of the region.

Concurrently, the Bioclimatic Mapping Project is committed to assessing the urban bio-climate in the southern Luxembourg region. The recommendations derived from this mapping effort will be closely associated with PRO-SUD’s involvement in the Cool Neighbourhood Interreg Northwest programme, which is designed to address urban heat challenges. This initiative marks a significant advancement in fostering the development of sustainable and resilient cities through meticulous data collection and analysis. The results will be publicly available towards the end of 2024.

The localisation of the UNESCO Minett Biosphere (Source: https://minett-biosphere.com/en/our-biosphere/)

Genesis and Composition

After the Luxembourg UNESCO Commission began discussing the first biosphere reserve in the Grand-Duchy in 2016 and followed by 4 years of multidisciplinary work to complete the application, the Minett region was officially recognized as such in October 2020, making Luxembourg part of the scientific Man and the Biosphere (MAB) programme. This programme promotes the conservation of biodiversity by engaging inhabitants, educating, researching, and supporting regional initiatives for sustainable development. The Minett Biosphere presents a fascinating juxtaposition: abandoned mines transformed into biodiversity havens, alongside ongoing human activity within dedicated transition zones. The Minett biosphere encompasses a region significantly impacted by iron ore extraction, leaving behind a distinct industrial legacy evident in its topography and cultural heritage.

PRO-SUD coordinated the application process and organized citizen consultations. Founded in 2003, the syndicate is a regional development union comprising 11 municipalities in southern Luxembourg. PRO-SUD, with the support of the Spatial Planning Department, is committed to promoting sustainable development in the region through various projects encompassing economic development, environmental protection, and social well-being.

Activities

The Minett UNESCO Biosphere advocates for biodiversity conservation and sustainable development, engaging citizens in educational efforts and research. It offers logistical assistance to projects focused on environmental education, multidisciplinary, regional and cross border collaboration with a commitment to fostering socio-culturally and environmentally sustainable economic and human development.

The post-industrial landscape of the region highlights the potential for ecological resilience, with diverse flora and fauna now flourishing in former mining sites. However, managing the delicate balance between environmental protection and ongoing growing human activity remains a huge challenge. To address this, the biosphere employs a strategic zoning system comprised of:

  • Core areas (zone centrale): Dedicated to research and conservation, strictly limiting human intervention.
  • Buffer zones (zone tampon): Surrounding core areas, these zones aim to minimize the impact of human activities.
  • Transition areas (zone de transition): Allow responsible human activities like agriculture and development.
The territory of the UNESCO Minett Biosphere (Source: https://minett-biosphere.com/en/our-biosphere/)

The territorial vision delineates a comprehensive developmental blueprint for the Minett region, encapsulating six pivotal objectives to ensure project alignment with overarching sustainable development objectives:

  1. Sustainable development: Pursuing a holistic approach that integrates environmental, economic, and social dimensions.
  2. Territorial cohesion: Mitigating socio-economic disparities across the region.
  3. Attractiveness and vibrancy: Augmenting the quality of life of residents and businesses.
  4. Ecological transition: Attaining climate neutrality and safeguarding biodiversity.
  5. Governance and participation: Advocating for participatory decision-making processes and citizen involvement.
  6. Resilience and adaptability: Anticipating and preparing for future challenges to ensure sustained regional viability.

The collaborative initiative, Mission Zero Carbone, epitomizes this vision, rallying the 11 municipalities within the Minett Biosphere towards achieving regional carbon neutrality by 2050. Each municipality formulates its action plan in alignment with the mission’s overarching objectives, addressing localized challenges and opportunities. Collaborative endeavours facilitate knowledge exchange, resource consolidation, and joint implementation of impactful projects across the region.

An initial project under this framework is the Bioclimatic Mapping initiative, generating pivotal data and analyses on the urban bio-climate of the Minett Biosphere. Initiated in response to a municipality architect’s request for more precise bioclimatic data to inform sustainable urban development strategies, this mapping project employs climate scenarios—specifically the RCP4.5 scenario—to project climatic conditions. Utilizing the 25th and 75th percentiles of temperature distribution (17.5°C and 19.5°C, respectively) instead of mean values, it offers a nuanced understanding of potential climate impacts.

PRO-SUD has commissioned the Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST) to spearhead this project, leveraging diverse methodologies such as remote sensing, on-site measurements, and citizen science initiatives over an 18-month duration until the project’s conclusion in late 2024. The resultant data will inform the development of a comprehensive climate model for the region, guiding decision-makers in formulating effective emissions reduction strategies.

Outlook

Mission Zero Carbone represents a significant challenge, yet it is pivotal for the Minett Biosphere to attain its climate goals and contribute to the Territorial Vision.  he Bioclimatic Map, furnishing invaluable data and analysis, plays a crucial role in guiding strategic actions and ensuring the first mission’s success to develop regional collaboration between the 11 municipalities. For those interested in the UNESCO Biosphere in southern Luxembourg, the website provides insights into its initiatives for achieving climate neutrality and other impactful projects. Further information can be found on the Minett Biosphere’s website.

Contact

Gaëlle Tavernier: prosud@prosud.lu

References

Minett Biosphere: (English, French and German): https://minett-biosphere.com/en/

Mission Zero Carbone: (English): https://minett-biosphere.com/en/news/mission-zero-carbone-kick-off-meeting-3/

Vision territorial (French): https://minett-biosphere.com/lu/projects/vision-territoriale-3/

Project ClimProSud (English and French): https://www.list.lu/fr/recherche/projet/climprosud/?no_cache=1&tx_listprojects_listprojectdisplay%5Barchive%5D=&cHash=ac5bde4a60223253a34e3f5ad42ffb87 Analysing the Urban Bioclimate of the South (Project ClimProSud (English, French, German, Luxembourgish): https://minett-biosphere.com/en/news/analysing-the-urban-bioclimate-of-the-south/